What is your reckon our political system works? Maybe similar to this. The public votes for MPs. They vote on bills. When a majority is secured, the bills are enacted as law. Statutes is maintained by the courts. End of story. However, that used to be how it operated in the past. Those days are over.
The Rise of Shadow Arbitration Panels
Today, international firms, along with the billionaires behind them, can sue nation states for the policies they pass, at private courts made up of commercial attorneys. These proceedings take place away from public scrutiny. Differing from national judiciaries, these tribunals grant no right of appeal or legal review. Ordinary citizens are unable to file a case to them, nor can our government, including businesses based in this country. They are open solely for corporations operating from foreign soil.
If a tribunal finds that a law or policy might diminish the corporation’s projected profits, it has the power to grant damages of vast sums, potentially billions.
This compensation represent not actual losses but funds the arbitrators decide the company might otherwise have made. The administration could be forced to drop the legislation. It becomes deterred from introducing similar legislation of a similar nature, for fear of being sued.
A Mechanism Running Rampant
Record numbers of cases are being initiated, as corporations observe each other, and private equity bankroll lawsuits for a share of a cut of the takings. The outcome? Democratic sovereignty and democratic governance are turning into too costly.
The system is referred to as “investor-state dispute settlement” (ISDS). The rationale it is allowed to override domestic law and the choices taken by elected bodies is that this stipulation has been incorporated – without public consent, and often in an atmosphere of profound opacity – into bilateral investment treaties.
A Real-World Case: The Cumbrian Coal Mine
Last year, environmental campaigners secured a significant win at the high court. The judge found that plans to excavate the first deep coalmine in the UK for three decades, in northwest England, had been wrongly permitted by the outgoing administration, which had agreed to the extraordinary assertion that the mine could have no consequence on climate commitments. The Labour government subsequently revoked the permission the previous administration had approved. Now, this legal outcome could be compromised by an foreign court answering to no one but the companies bringing the case.
During August, a company whose ultimate owners reside in the offshore financial centre lodged a claim against the UK government. The previous week a tribunal in the United States was set up to consider the case.
This firm is suing the UK for the profits it would have generated if the mine had received permission to go ahead. We have little idea how much this sum represents. Which individual is serving as its counsel challenging the UK administration? An elected representative, and former attorney-general in the Conservative government, the noted patriot Geoffrey Cox. The administration passes a law, the national judiciary validates it, then a foreign company disputes it through an undemocratic arbitration panel, and a sitting MP works for its behalf.
A Sanctions Case
On the same day that the court on the mining lawsuit was convened, it was revealed from a ministerial statement that the UK faces another lawsuit under ISDS by a wealthy Russian individual, a sanctioned individual. The public knows little of the case to date, but it appears probable that he’ll use the ISDS mechanism to contest the sanctions the UK enacted against him following the Russian aggression. He has already initiated proceedings against Luxembourg on these grounds, claiming a colossal sum: equivalent to half of government’s yearly budget. Part of the lawyers acting for him in that case? a prominent lawyer, wife of the ex-UK leader.
International law scholars contend that the EU’s delay in utilising seized Russian assets as collateral for its loan to Ukraine is due to Belgium’s fear that it could be subject to litigation in the secret arbitration panels, under a investment pact. This remarkable, undemocratic power over elected governments may be obstructing the finance Ukraine urgently requires.
Empty Promises and Growing Risks
We were assured that such things could not occur. Years ago, a government leader, championing the largest and riskiest of all investment pacts, stated: “Britain has agreed to trade agreement upon trade deal and we have never seen a issue in the past.” A consultant on this matter described campaigners of “scaremongering … the truth is, ISDS has little impact on the UK much”. The prevailing narrative appeared to be that exclusively weaker states needed to fear these lawsuits. Warnings that “when companies grasp the authority they now possess, they will shift their focus from the vulnerable countries to the developed economies” were dismissed with general mockery.
That warning is now a reality. In the current period, fossil fuel and resource corporations have lodged a unprecedented number of claims against nations both wealthy and developing, opposing – like the example of the UK mine – official measures to stop environmental catastrophe. Firms have thus far won $114bn via ISDS, of which energy giants have obtained $84bn. That equates to the combined GDP